Best Weapons in Roblox: Murder Mystery 2, Ranked

Summary

The best MM2 weapons are valued based on aesthetics, reputation, and rarity.
Unique weapons like the Corrupt, Candy Set, and Nik’s Scythe hold high prestige in the community.
Harvester, with premium value and exceptional design, sets the standard for MM2 weapons.

In the world of Roblox’s Murder Mystery 2 (MM2), the right weapon can make or break a round—whether players are slicing through the chaos as the Murderer or staring down fate as the Sheriff. Each knife and gun is a status symbol, a strategic choice, and sometimes, a flex that speaks louder than words in the lobby. So, what really makes a weapon “the best” in MM2? It’s not just looks or rarity; it’s a mix of utility, community prestige, and market power.

Some weapons draw stares for their aesthetics, others for their in-game legacy or raw value on the trading block. And, because MM2’s one-hit-kill system makes every weapon equally lethal, even subtle differences in weapon models, hitbox reliability, and visibility can make all the difference. So, here’s the definitive list of MM2’s best weapons, where every entry has earned its place through its status and rarity.

8

Chroma Lightbringer

Color-Shifting Prestige at Its Peak

The Chroma Lightbringer is the best of the “Chroma” line, cycling through a rainbow of colors in a display that’s impossible to ignore. Pulled from the coveted Mystery Crate 2, this godly weapon is the very definition of a flex item for Sheriffs who want all eyes on them.

From a gameplay standpoint, the Chroma Lightbringer behaves just like the regular Lightbringer. The real power is in its reputation. When players spot the shifting colors, players know someone with serious trading prowess (or ridiculous luck) is on the field.

7

Heartblade

For the Pink Aesthetic and the Die-Hard Fans

Heartblade is the weapon of choice for anyone who loves a pink, dreamy, or Valentine’s Day aesthetic. Its sleek design with a prominent heart-shaped guard has made it a beloved staple in the MM2 community, especially among players who love to coordinate avatars around a strong, themed look.

Performance-wise, the Heartblade delivers reliable functionality with a standard knife hitbox that players can trust. Heartblade holds a place of honor for fans who appreciate the romance and fun of MM2’s seasonal events. Despite its relatively thin design, the weapon’s unique vibe gives it a value that goes beyond numbers.

6

Corrupt

The Collector’s Legend That Was Born Out of a Glitch

Corrupt was awarded during the infamous “Data Loss Glitch” as a form of compensation. This unique-tier blade is filled with lore and nostalgia, and it has a model that’s both simple and unmistakably “glitched.”

Despite a market influx from the later “Duping Glitch,” Corrupt remains a collector’s centerpiece, regularly fetching high prices and sparking heated debates in the forum. It’s the MM2 equivalent of owning a misprinted baseball card: the value comes from the story, the rarity, and the connection to a unique moment in the game’s timeline.

5

The Candy Set (Candy & Sugar)

OG Sweat Status and Classic Power

The Candy Set (Candy & Sugar) - Murder Mystery 2

Seers: 340 Seers (combined)

Few weapon sets in Murder Mystery 2 are as iconic as the Candy knife and Sugar gun. With a combined 340 Seers in trading value, this festive duo has become an OG set among players and a must-have for anyone looking to show off its deep MM2 design.

With bold, candy cane stripes and high trading values, the Candy Set comes with both nostalgia and social power. Reliable hitboxes and sharp design make both weapons solid choices in battle, but the reputation means players often expect a tough fight whenever they’re on the field.

4

The Icebreaker Set (Icebreaker & Iceblaster)

Heavyweight Presence That Commands Respect

The Icebreaker Set (Icebreaker & Iceblaster) - Murder Mystery 2

Seers: 215 Seers (combined)

If size truly matters, the Icebreaker set is king. Featuring one of the largest knife models in the game, this set (from the Xmas 2020 event) is built for players who want their presence felt the second they join a round. The Icebreaker axe is pure visual intimidation, while the matching Iceblaster gun brings a cold style to the Sheriff’s arsenal.

On the trading market, both weapons fetch premium prices (a combined trading value of around 215 Seers), and for good reason: the psychological impact is undeniable. Rounds can take on a different tempo when someone’s swinging an axe that takes up half the screen. Winning in MM2 is as much about getting into an opponent’s head as it is about landing the final blow.

3

Nik’s Scythe

Unobtainable Legend and the Ultimate Flex

Seers: 145,000 + Seers

If Murder Mystery 2 had a hall of fame, Nik’s Scythe would be under glass. This is the personal blade of the game’s creator, Nikilis, which is granted only by the developer and tracked by the community like a mythical artifact.

The deep red and black scythe design is instantly recognizable, but the real value comes from sheer unobtainability. Players dream of owning Nik’s Scythe, but almost none ever will. The weapon serves as MM2‘s ultimate status symbol, the item that makes every other “rare” weapon seem common by comparison.

2

Swirly Axe

Setting New Standards for Weapon Design

Swirly Axe is the weapon that redefined Murder Mystery 2’s sense of visual flair. With a mesmerizing swirl animation rippling across the blade, this Ancient-tier knife that commands values of 200+ Seers quickly became the new gold standard for what a high-value collectible can be.

Swirly Axe holds value for several reasons: it’s technically impressive, beautiful to look at, and surprisingly reliable in the heat of gameplay. When it was first released as a simple event reward, few anticipated its dramatic rise in value. As players recognized the uniqueness of its animation technology, demand skyrocketed, establishing a new premium tier for weapons that pushed technical boundaries.

1

Harvester

The Benchmark for Premium MM2 Weapons

The Harvester gun stands as Murder Mystery 2’s closest approximation to a perfect weapon, commanding an impressive 1,010 Seers in trading value while excelling in almost every category that matters. Released as a reward for the 2021 Halloween Event, Harvester is beloved for its jaw-dropping model, signature sound effects, and all-around polish.

The booming crossbow sound is instantly recognizable, the visual presence is unmatched, and it’s without a doubt one of the most satisfying weapons to wield. The weapon has become the benchmark against which all future event rewards will be measured, establishing a template for what players expect from premium MM2 content.